HOME / How do the Dementia Diarists experience Call Centres?

How do the Dementia Diarists experience Call Centres?

For many people living with dementia, using and communicating via traditional phones is extremely challenging. During the course of the Dementia Diaries project a number of diarists have reflected on the significant impact this has on their lives, affecting their sense of independence and isolation.

Here, 9 participants share their experience of communicating with companies via call centres – a task that can be frustrating for anyone, but which poses particular difficulties for people living with dementia. As Keith Oliver explains, feeling unable to communicate with service providers over the phone “affects my sense of independence. It affects my self-confidence and my self-esteem. Consequently I tend to be even more anxious about making other calls.”

The reports below were compiled for the ‘Inclusion and Accessibility Team’ at BT and will help inform service improvements they are making for people living with dementia.

 

How do we feel before contacting a call centre?

Many of us find the prospect of contacting a call centre incredibly stressful. You’ll see common themes and experiences are anxiety, dread, fear, pressure and embarrassment, with the result that a number of us “just don’t bother.”

 

“I dread dealing with companies on the phone. It’s so stressful. Where do I start? I plan it all out, pin and password at the ready. Eventually I get through to a robot with six options. Listen to all, forget the one I need, make a mistake and you’re back at the beginning. Waiting in the queue for a human. Music blaring at the other end, forget you have phoned, ask more security questions. They talk too quickly and give you too much information. They don’t listen; they have to follow the company line and push for you to commit to something.”

Anne MacDonald, Glasgow


“I use the phone as rarely as possible. Now if I have to make a phone call, even to my best friend, I will procrastinate for absolutely ages, I really have to psych myself up before dialing the number. I know it’s like meeting a friend, and once you get there, it’s absolutely fine. But, making that call, even to a good friend, is really, really difficult.”

Jo Bennett, Stockport


“The thought of making such calls now makes me feel very anxious.  I’m happy to phone my local garage to book the car in for a service etc, but that’s about my limit.  I know that I’m not going to have to answer questions – they’ll suggest a date, and it’s either a ‘yes’ or a ‘no’, and that’s it. The problem is I’m frightened of being put in the position of having to answer unexpected questions – and then I feel that there is a time pressure – that they’ll want an answer quickly – but I would need more time to think about the questions – and they won’t realise this so they’ll ask another question, or even just repeat the first question.  This then interrupts my train of thought, and I have to start thinking about the question and answer again. It’s all too embarrassing and stressful. By not being able to make these calls it feels so demeaning. I can’t bring myself to make these calls independently. I feel so frustrated with myself. I feel I should be able to make these calls. My mind goes blank. It highlights that I need help. I hate that too. Carol is already busy doing lots of things and I hate not feeling that I can help out.”

Chris Forse, Bedford


“Personally the whole system is a no no for me and I know a lot of other people with dementia they just don’t use their phones. It gets to the point where it gets that bad that people with dementia don’t answer their home phones either. It’s very rare I’ll answer unless I’m expecting someone to call me. In one respect my phone bill might be small, but on the other hand you lose communication with people.”

Paul Hitchmough, Liverpool


“Usually I feel anxious about calling companies, but it depends on how I feel. Some days I would be more anxious than others. On those days I would ask my wife to call for me. Other times I feel more comfortable and with extra preparation, thinking things through and thinking about the call, making notes – that helps. I sometimes get worried that they have little understanding of the lasting power of attorney, but more on that later.”

Keith Oliver, Kent


What worries us when we’re on a call?

All of us find robotic call handling systems a real challenge – it’s “the biggest difficulty”. For some, any automation at all will cause us to give up, whilst others find it difficult to cope with more than one or two options. 

“Particularly on the automated calls systems; it’s like being deaf. It’s an absolute no-no. If I don’t get through first time, or second time, then I just don’t bother. Nobody in my experience with dementia does, it’s just too confusing. Far too many steps… If they ask you to do something you’ve forgotten the steps by the time you’re supposed to do it, it’s all a mish mash, I just don’t bother – it’s just impossible for me to use it.”

Paul Hitchmough, Liverpool


“The automated call system is a problem and often there are too many steps to remember. Anything beyond three is pretty hopeless for me and I guess most other people with dementia feel that way. One tends to forget what the last few options are. The last one knocks out the previous in your mind. That’s the biggest barrier of speaking to these companies. It’s much better to speak to a person, if these companies realised that someone with dementia had this difficulty and maybe we were given a direct number to a person that would help a lot… Also, waiting for a person to answer the phone – there have been occasions when I’ve forgotten who I was ringing and why I was ringing them. And all the preparation that goes on beforehand is wasted. I know that many people find waiting frustrating on these systems, but when you’ve got dementia it’s even worse”

Keith Oliver, Kent


“With a call centre, anything more than one step is too many – I might think about making some calls if I could speak to a person right away.  I suppose that would make the process less worrying or difficult.”

Chris Forse, Bedford


“Another thing is, you’re passed round to different people, and you’ve managed to get so far, you have to start all over again, you know: name, address, all this… I just put the phone down it’s just a no-no. Another nightmare.”

Paul Hitchmough, Liverpool


We’ve had different experiences of interacting with customer service representatives – and have different coping strategies for making conversations as straightforward as possible. Whilst some of us volunteer the information that we have dementia, others choose not to, for fear that it won’t help – or worried that we will be left trying to explain the condition to someone who doesn’t understand.

“I haven’t ever told a customer services person about my difficulties and worries.  I guess I might consider this if I knew the person on the other end of the phone had an understanding – or was trained  to deal with people who need more time to answer questions.  They’d need to be trained in “how to listen” – and to have lots of patience! I don’t suppose this will ever happen as it wouldn’t be cost effective.”

Chris Forse, Bedford


“I don’t really mind [calling call centres], there’s only one company called Talk Talk that I’ve had problems with because the call centre is not a UK based one and I had to repeat myself continually and continually and in the end I told them I had dementia and they didn’t know what it was! I’ve actually come out of Talk Talk for that reason and I’m with Sky now… I had a lot of problems because my daughter had power of attorney and it didn’t turn out right and I’ve got my Social Worker to deal with some people because she was my Social Worker and sounded official; she seemed to deal with it better than me on my own behalf. I get really frustrated when they don’t understand why I’ve phoned to explain something. I don’t say right away that I’ve got dementia; I say I’ll just get someone else to phone. If I do get really frustrated I’ll say to them, “I’m sorry, but I have dementia, so if you could just bear with me and speak a bit more slowly back to me then I’ll try and explain to you. It’s not rocket science, what I’m speaking to you about. I’m not stupid. And they’ll go ‘Oh, I’m sorry to hear that.'”

Carol Ovenstone, Glagow


“I don’t say I’ve got dementia unless I get confused then I’ll say, I have an illness. And if they’re talking on and on when I’m fatigued and confused, I’m just going to put the phone down. With all the phone calls you get from abroad, to be honest, if it’s a foreign voice – I’ll often just put the phone straight down.”

Archie Latta, Glasgow


“If I get through to a customer service person I tell them I have dementia. Sometimes that helps and sometimes it doesn’t. It does serve to probably make them more understanding of the conversation they’re going to have, but often they still talk too fast or give too many instructions… I think [it would help] if the big companies, the big utility companies, considered giving their staff – particularly those on the frontline – some kind of dementia friends training, so that they were better placed to support us and keep us living independently for as long as possible. These utility companies have a big responsibility as do banks and so on.”

Keith Oliver, Kent


“Why should I have to come out and say [‘I have dementia’] if I don’t have to say it straight away? I normally tell people if they start to give me any hassle. You know, if a taxi driver starts to be a bit funny with me or something, I’ll say “look I’ve got dementia.” And then they all change their minds. It’s like playing the sympathy vote, sometimes for me, that I say it. I don’t want to feel like that – I want to be independent without saying I’ve got dementia… I could just say ‘it’s going to take me a bit longer to understand, please speak to me slowly and try and explain what’s happened and that’ll make it much easier for both of us’. I should really do that.”

Carol Ovenstone, Kent


 

How straightforward is it for our carers to make calls?

Many of us ask our carers to make calls on our behalf (although this isn’t an option for everyone). As you’ll see below, agreeing lasting ‘power of attorney’ can be a real pain.

 

“Chris had upgraded his mobile phone in a shop and not been offered insurance.  Some months later I realised this, and phoned on his behalf to add insurance.  It got very complicated [with them] speaking to me on Chris’s behalf.  I had explained about his memory problems but they insisted he needed to speak to them, and then they insisted that he needed to listen to a 6 minute script detailing terms and conditions etc.  They wouldn’t let me listen and confirm on his behalf (I did explain that not only did I make all the phone calls, but that I also did all the household accounts and was in fact trying to PAY them some money!).  Finally they offered a compromise: go into our local shop and arrange with a real person.  Success – we thought! But when we arrived, they then played this 6 minute T&C scrip out loud in the shop in front of all customers, and we had to stand there and listen like lemons! It was very embarrassing and quite honestly appalling customer service.”

Carol Forse (Chris Forse’ partner), Bedford


 

“Giving call handlers a greater understanding of lasting power of attorney [would be helpful] because so often they don’t seem to have any understanding of how it works. They will only speak to the person whose name is on the bill or on the account and often that’s me which is unfortunate because my wife is better placed to deal with them.”

Keith Oliver, Kent


 

What other issues are there?

An issue that many of us struggling with is the impact that ‘cold calls’ have on our confidence, undermining our willingness to talk to any companies over the phone. In a context where making and taking any call can be emotionally very draining, frequent cold calls are one reason that many of us are reluctant to answer the phone at all.  In addition, some of us worry about scams and succumbing to pressure to make quick decisions we might later regret.

 

“Cold callers are the bane of so many people’s lives. Relentless silent calls, or “You had an accident?” or some other rubbish… If I look and it’s an 088 number, I think “I’m not picking that up,” but it could be the doctors! And if you don’t answer it you may get blacklisted, which no-one wants. I don’t need any of this stress… There are so many scams and charlatans out there who prey on vulnerable people. Particularly targeting older people, and this includes people with dementia”

Anne MacDonald, Glasgow


 

“I told them that I have dementia, and that it’s devastating because we don’t need it on top of my wife’s disability and my dementia… I can’t explain how the feeling is. It is horrendous. We haven’t spoken to BT, what’s the point? I’ve phoned up two or three times and it’s still happening. I mean, it’s all automated, computerised, all the numbers withheld. I keep saying “how did you get my number” and they just won’t answer. Mentally, on top of Jan’s illnesses and mine, it’s just horrendous. There’s nothing BT can do, the ladies on the end of the phone keep saying there’s nothing they can do about it. It’s these insurance companies that’ve obviously given you the number and that’s it… We only give out our number to people like family, the plumber, the electrician, friends, people from Forget-me-nots, psychologists.”

Melvyn Brooks, Kent


We haven’t had much luck getting cold calls blocked by our phone companies – with the result that some of us are exploring other options. 

“Our friend Jackie recommended the BT8500 Advanced Call Blocker phone.  We printed off the info from the BT website – it was  very easy to understand and explained the phone features really well.  We especially liked the little photos and illustrations that explained the process so clearly and was much easier to understand than just paragraphs of text.  I printed a copy from the website for Chris to sit and read in his own time… Lots of the features look helpful; we particularly liked the “Do not disturb” option.  If you tag specifc people as VIP (e.g. close family that you’d want to speak to whatever), then they will still be able to get through on the phone.  All other calls presumably go straight to answer phone as the explanations states that the phone  won’t ring or light up… This feature would be So helpful on ‘bad days’, or perhaps if the carer was unwell, so it wouldn’t put unnecessary pressure on the call  needing to be dealt with.  People with memory and dementia problems often have ‘bad’ or ‘wobbly’ days, and so on those days they can make things easier for themselves… It’s quite expensive – especially when we have a phone that works well and isn’t that old.  It’s a shame that BT don’t offer a “try before you buy” option.  As we’d need to pay for the phone and handset extension, and then also pay a monthly fee for Caller Display, I’d like to be convinced that Chris will use it and that it will work for him – otherwise we’ll have paid all this extra money for nothing.  If I still answer and make all the phone calls, then our current phone is fine.”

Carol Forse, Bedford


“Some days, I just don’t answer the phone. What I do is, if a phone call comes through, I will let it go and pick it up, check, call back to see who it is. If it is somebody I do want to speak to, I think I can call them back. It’s a pain, having to do that! It’s just so annoying, and a bit disturbing sometimes, how much pressure some of them will try to put on you to buy something or contribute to something.”

Regina Shaw, Liverpool


In an ideal world,  big companies would provide contact options specifically for vulnerable groups, including people living with dementia.

“Being able to talk “face to face” might help – for example by Skype. People could pick up on body language. They could see that I was still there, and getting my thoughts together – and they wouldn’t need to keep prompting as they could see I was trying to give an answer.  On the phone I feel compelled to give a speedy answer, so I’m more likely to just agree –  or say anything, right or not – just to give an answer and bring the call closer to a finish.”

Chris Forse, Bedford


“We’ve talked about how things might be changed “in a perfect dementia-friendly world”.  We wondered if big companies or government departments could let “vulnerable people” (not just dementia sufferers) register with them and then there could be an option on the initial menu to get through to a real person… Maybe even if you had to enter a pin number or password to enable access to a ‘real person’  (though this adds more to do and it might be a problem for some) this would be an improvement!  It would help to retain some independence for the person with memory, cognitive or diagnosed dementia problems.”

Carol Forse, Bedford

 

Other diary entries you might like...

(filed under Archive 2015)

More from ...

Sorry, we couldn't find any and more posts from this diarist.

Scroll to Top